User blog comment:RoninTheMasterless/Reexamining Earth-51/@comment-6548012-20151211131319

First off, I find it great that you come back to another reality because you feel like it's rather undeveloped, it shows exactly the devotion you have to your own creations, and that's a thing that frankly, is quite comforting.

William Todd was a great idea, a new concept, and an intelligent thought&mdash;but now he's replaced by Jason Todd, well you know my feelings about that, on paper, it doesn't great at all, to replace a semi-original character with someone that's pretty much the star of a lot of your realities already, so, as far as I am concerned, that's a regression to me, especially if the base story is pretty much the same, except merged with Batman Beyond. To reassure myself, though, I'll count on his adventures more than his origins and personality, and that isn't bad, really. It actually makes me think of another comic book hero, which you've portrayed as well, and just as nicely.

But Superman over here, is definitely a big step. You take things that I totally despise, such as Snyder/Nolan's decisions, the DCEU's changes, and the sometimes unnecessary Batman/Superman rivalry, and you weld them to your agreements, and the way you say it, you're making changes that at least one person has been waiting for all along concerning him, so here, the concept is a really good thing, but you know the deal with Superman fanfiction, when the origin story is the same or slightly different, you can't say much else about it unless you see the hero's adventures, which kinda makes you think that he is a very, very good comic book character.

Clearly not an important character by his development, I'm guessing. The origin is a let's get this over with type of thing, and yet he's related to the bigger characters, so I'm guessing that he is more of a comic-book cool, and I like it.

Well, there's literally nothing to say about her. Is she going to be the same as the original, or a slightly new character? This reminds me of your other Raven, the Alternate Earth-53 version, who doesn't have that many adventures to marvel at.

Same as Holt. Rapid origin, unestablished at the beginning, and a character who doesn't totally make too much sense, but surely has a great potential for adventures, but I'll come to that later.

It's sad&mdash;I was hoping to see a more important Batgirl than that, but I guess there's no point of going any further than that, because I have a precise idea of what I think this all means.

By observation, I have the fervent idea that Earth-51 is not a typical reality here. I have the feeling that it's more of a real comic-book universe. You put all these characters on the same plan as Batman and Superman, yet in terms of development and ideas, the two are much more important than the small, insignificant outsiders. Every character seems rapidly created, rapidly introduced, rapidly thrown into the action, making them ready for adventures. Their origin doesn't mean anything, and it's mostly because their origin is unimportant, they're there for experiencing shit. If I'm right, this can be a good universe. If it's not at all your intention, then excuse me, but the development value has regressed, and the reality probably won't be great.