User blog:The Ultimate Thinker/The Fictional Critic 05: The Special Episode

The Fictional Critic is a segment published by the Great Lord David criticizing various pages of Comic Crossroads. With our reviewers, the mysterious "F" and Artemis, every episode will count with a number of reviews whether heroes, villains, realities or even fan fiction issues but today not only do we have some extra things like an exclusive interview, a game and also some very important announcements that you simply cannot miss. Multiple seasons are expected with the segment´s increasing comments ajd sucess.

Information of the Fictional Critic

 * The Fictional Critic is published daily on Mondays, Wednesdays and also Fridays at 23:59 p.m  by the The Great Lord David.
 * As to terms of opinion this is perfectly legal and falls within the Comic Crossright, to which any sort of copying is not allowed unless allowed by the author and the other members of the Fictional Critic.
 * The goal of this project is to give other users the knowledge of pages, either good or bad, any kind.
 * "F" was our only reviewer, but Artemis Thorson has joined the show in this episode, being his great debut on the 4th episode of the Fictional Critic.
 * The Fictional Critic is in episode 5 of Season 1.
 * Season 1 will have 26 segments and a special episode with a number of 160 reviews in totality.
 * Leave your ideas, opinions and even your reviews on the comments above as we would like to know what you think.
 * I hope you enjoy our show as we have lots of new events, fantastic reviews and simply a program you can´t and won´t miss. Thank you for your time.

Who is "F"?Edit
"F" is our anonymus reviewer and not only is he a Comic Crossroads user but he is also a professional reviewer. He mainly publishes his reviews on several sites, but also including his work are reviews on several DC and mainly Marvel Fanfiction Wikis. His secret identity is a secret know only to me but it will be revealed when the time is right. He is a great reviewer, always speaking the truth, either about good or bad pages and he is someone with a vast experience.

The "F" stands for Fanfiction and but he is one of the essential pilars of the show, the reviewer and has become a friend of mine. I hope you enjoy his reviews and that you wonder about his true identity.

Would you like to meet "F"?
On the last episode of the Fictional Critic it was announced that 3 users from Comic Crossroads that were interested in meeting "F" would be allowed to have a 25 minutes chat with him personally. And so he now announce the winners of the contest. Congratulations to our winners: The chat will later be decided upon time and place with all three winners. The chats with "F" will later be published on the sixth episode of the Fictional Critic, to be aired on Monday of the next week. Congratulations to our readers and thanks to all the participants for your support and help.
 * Uncanny X-Factor (done)
 * Lord Caesar (in progress)
 * RoninTheMasterless (in progress)

Requests
Any requests should be made on the comments above the show or also on my Message Wall, present in next link presented, The Great Lord David. All requests will be answered but those that include the subjects of removing, insulting or any others will be left unanswered and if continued, removed.

Also, what do you think of our new theme song,  I hope you enjoy it and hear it as you see our newest reviews. I have to thank FrenchTouch, for helping with me with the technological part behind the show. You can check for the other persons behind the project on our Team section.

F´s Reviews
And today we have a review for each user we consider actived. We have decided to review what F can consider one of the best pages of every user that has been editing in the wiki for the last 10. Remember that a special episode should have special reviews. Thank you for your time.

SigmaVerse
F: ''To begin this very special episode of the Fictional Critic, we begin with a page from Draft227, the Sigmaverse. As I said in older reviews, I really enjoyed the diversity of this page and it is my favourite reality until days ago, since I have found a new page that has overshadowed this one. But returning to the page at hand, the timeline is very original and the first of it´s kind in Comic Crossroads if I´m not mistaken and all the characters are very well written and designed, including the page for the reality itself. This reality possesses an almost infinite lists of great works, like the Scarecrow, Batman, Simon and many more. Draft has really done a magnificient job this time. I must congratulate him on his achievement as this is truly a work to be immensely proud of. To finish the first review of the night, I shall give this page a final score of '8,1 out of 10. 'It is really amazing and uncommon, to produce a work as great as this as his first on this fanfiction wiki. I see now that he is starting a new cinematic universe and he has other magnificient pages on Marvel Fanon. I will surely review them his future projects in future episodes but for now what counts is that Draft227 should be proud of this, of himself and of the masterpiece he has created.''

Final Review: 8,1/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

William Lawton (Earth-152312)
F: ''From my search in Comic Crossroads, no writer seems to achieve the quality and sucess that RoninTheMasterless has achieved, no author seems to achieve the fame and grandure of his articles and now I understand why. William Lawton of Earth-152312 is perfect in every way. It is by far the greatest fafiction page I have seen. Ronin is truly a writer. This character can be considered a new Spider-Man. I am really in shock, the originality from Batman, the complexity, the phrases, the perfection, months to create such work of art. I am really surprised. Earth-152312 is a great page on itself but this William not only is it 20 times better than the William I last reviewed but also it is twice as better than any page I have seen or will ever see. It is a diamond in the field of fanfiction and one of the burning lights of Comic Crossroads. This page is so amazing! Not only shall it remain in my memory as the page with the highest score I have ever given and as one of the greatest works of fanfiction I have ever seen but also it shall remain in the heart of Comic Crossroads as their greatest work, it shall remain as the Mona Lisa to the Louvre, it shall remain with a score of '10 out of 10. 'I believe now I am not even worthy of reading that work, let alone review it. Very impressive, very impressive indeed! How on earth has this page not won the Featured Article Nominating and Voting yet, people? Don´t be blind. ''

Final Review: 10/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Thor (Earth-1309)
F: ''And now a work from PhotonComander10. Thor proved to be one of the most complicated characters I have ever reviewed in terms of personality and it was very well written without a doubt, being complete until the very last phrase. The page is full of ground breaking battles, that envoke back in us the might of Norse mythology once again. It is truly a diamond in the field of fanfiction as well. A page rivaling the previous work I reviewed, is it a masterpiece with a quality and precision that cannot be measured. I too am really impressed with this work because I knew Photon was an excellent writer from his last works, but he just raised the bar and he raised it 20 times higher. The fact this page is loved by all and won the Featured Article Nominating and Voting of a month in 2013 shows it´s status as one of the greatest pages that has ever been written on this site. The image selection is great and this page is truly a hero of the highest caliber possible. As to finish the review of this incredible and amazing Thor, I shall give it a stunning review of '9,6 out of 10. 'I don´t know if Photon is capable of raising the bar once again but I know that doing that will be very difficult not because he doesn´t have the skills to, but because this page is so well written and so bathed in perfection it is a master piece that no one can copy and almost no one can surpass, perhaphs not even it´s creator, or in this case twice.''

Final Review: 9,6/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Earth-1600
F: ''Now we have a second of the three realities reviewed in today´s episode. This reality belongs to Lord Caesar, author of one of my favourite heroes in this site, Peter Parker of Earth-1600. Since I loved that character it would only be natural for me to review the reality that gave birth to that work of art. The truth is that Earth-1600 still needs to be worked but what has been worked until now is enough for a high score in my final review. I really adore the primitives and focus on these beings in this reality, plus dividing the attention with other super heroes and villains that have original traces and appear in amazing events. There is no doubt Earth-1600 is one of the most worked pages in Comic Crossroads, and probably the second most worked reality after Earth-1224. I must congratulate Caesar on his achievement with this page as it is a master piece. I am very impressed with this amazing work and to express the feelings that I felt while reading this page the day before, I shall give it a final score of '8,4 out of 10. 'I really hope not only to see more works of Caesar on Comic Crossroads but also to see Earth-1600 being completed and achieve the glory that the page and it´s creator truly deserves. It is very impressive, the dedication and the details, the mastery that Caesar has over his words and over the stories that he himself writes. ''

Final Review: 8,4/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Kal-El (Earth-929)
F: ''Now we have my first work by the hand of Last Scribe of Krypton and quite frankly it could not be a better one. Here we have a normal Superman but this character is once again very well written. However, the way Scribe makes, the words he uses to describe him, the events he faces, it truly represents the American Way better than anyone and makes me proud to be an American myself. It is a work anyone can enjoy. The image selection is just perfect, so colorful and chosen with great carefulness. There is also no doubt about this work itis very focused on details, possessing a very distinctive and unique Kal-El personality, a section of Power and Abilities that could not be more complete. His adventures are still in my mind has he faces all kinds of villains and as he escapes the doomed planet to become Superman on Earth. The truth is that Scribe has taken a classic hero and made it better, made into a masterpiece. He is not a very active user of Comic Crossroads but this page really deserved to be seen, read and also reviewed. It is a very impressive and awesome work and I can´t wait to see more by the mighty hand of Last Scribe. To finish the first review of this impressive user, I shall grant this page a final score of '9,4 ouf of 10. 'This page is what brings great joy to Crossroads´s DC Fanfiction Sections, is what brings joy to me and to thousands of people, to see there are people who still write like this, in such a perfect way that cannot be replicated. Bravo! I really loved your work, Scribe of Krypton and I hope to review it again.''

Final Review: 9,4/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Earth-1224
F: ''And now a page belonging to my dearest David, the great Earth-1224. What I love about this page, besides David´s mastery of details and of it´s stories is it´s diversity once again. He changes the stories so much that at one time, he turns Doom into a God, later comes Ultron, then the Spectre, then Galactus. The image selection is the best I have seen so far and the page is so complete and it shows so much hard work I am truly surprised. I didn´t know my publisher wrote that well, to write a work of such perfection whose final score will rival that of the previous William Lawton and Thor of Earth-1309. It is truly an amazing work but I have a word of caution of David. I can see you have put much work and effort in Earth-1224 and that you have not yet achieved half of what you truly pretend to with that reality but let me advise not to focuse all your ideas into one single page, Earth-1224 has that might prove to be a big mistake. Even so, this page is now my favourite reality and it is not only the best reality I have seen on any wiki so far, it is also one of the pages who receives the highest score tonight. To end this review, I shall grant Earth-1224 a final score of '9,8 out of 10. 'I await for David´s other works but now my expectations are as high as ever for his next work and Earth-1224 is not going to be a work easy to surpass.''

Final Review: 9,8/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Wolverine: The Animated Series
F: ''And now we have a work from Tekken LSSJ. Now doubt he has put a lot of thinking into Wolverine: The Animated Series. The episodes are well chosen as Wolverine teams up with several super heroes and the season themselves each are very organized and encompass a different them. They also involve many of the characters that make the X-Men universe along with many others and the idea of creating a series for just Wolverine is actually the first I have seen but the truth is that Wolverine is a hero as a great as the likes of Wolverine and Iron Man and this is a very smart idea. I truly await for the future season, especially Season 3 and Season 4 that appear to be the most exicting as Season 1 has demonstrated to be a very amazing piece of television. To finish my review, I shall grant this page a final score of '7,2 out of 10. 'I really hope for Tekken´s next work, especially since all his works are in some way related to media, being them Television Seies or Movies and Films. I really enjoyed reading and reviewing this page and Tekken has done a nice job with his new series.''

Final Review: 7,2/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Eliot Tessa (Earth-3)
F: ''And now we have a page from my beloved Artemis, the master and god of fanfiction. And this time it is one of his heavy hitters, the mighty Eliot Tessa. To say the truth, I am a big fan of the Green Lantern univers, especially Hal Jordan and this page has without a doubt become my favourite Green Lantern of all. He is will power personified, courage and power. He is well written but then again that is one of Artemis´s defining traces that make him a special writer. It is a page full of imagination, of detail and that is what I love in Eliot. There is no doubt this character is a masterpiece in everyway, as are all of Artemis´s new One Shot Characters. They are simply amazing. The page is simply perfect and one of my favourite heroes so far in Comic Crossroads and while Peter Parker marks the new Artemis, this Eliot marks the old Artemis. The change is obvious but the quality has remained the same. To conclude my review of my own fellow reviewer, I shall give Artemis Thorson´s page a final score of '9,2 ouf of 10. 'It is truly a masterpiece but it is already one I was expecting from his genius brain. His works have raised in me great thoughts about Artemis´s work and all I know is he is an excellent writer and produces works of unmatchable quality.''

Final Review: 9,2/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Franklin Green (Earth-X)
F: ''And now we have a work from Bluehunter16. As I told him in the last review, what he wrote about Doctor Strange was not fanfiction but Franklin Green of Earth-X sure is and one of good quality. It is no doubt one of the pages he put effort and hard work in and it payed off. It is an amazing work. The original character starts with a cowboy but later not only does he die but he returns as a ghost and this very same character combines a bit of various series including one of my favourites, Ghost Rider. I really enjoyed this new piece of work. The text, the categories and the page itself are all in order and this is truly a reversal of fortune as Bluehunter is about to achieve a very positive review. As to finish my review on the second of Bluehunter16´s works, I shall grant it a '7,1 out of 10. 'Did I like the page? Of course, I did. Am I satisfied? No, because this is still nothing, nothing compared to what Bluehunter is really capable of doing. He is master of writing and a  master of creating and innovation and I impatiently await to review another one of his works.''

Final Review: 7,1/10

Do you agree with F´s review?

Franklin Richards (Earth-1175)
F: ''And now to complete my own reviews there is a page from the authory of Uncanny X-Factor. I would like to say I really enjoyed the fact he used an image of the Human Torch to pose as Franklin Richards. The plot and the origins are very ingenious. He has once again created page that is very ingenious, very well written and that reminds me that Uncanny X-Factor is indeed a genius. Earth-1175, as well as the Sigmaverse, Earth-1224 and finally Earth-1600 have all become some of my favourite realities and the idea of Franklin Richards being a member of the Fantastic Five is completly terrific. To end my last review of this very special episode, I shall grant Uncanny X-Factor´s page a total score of '7,8 out of 10. 'Not only am I grateful that X-Factor showed the wonders of Marvel Fanon but I really enjoyed my chat with him and I think he is a true fanfiction writer and a loyal friend. Congratulations! You have amazing works and great potential.''

Artemis´s Reviews
Edward Brock (Earth-848)

Artemis: ''Venom is my favorite villain of all-time, so of course I'm going to think this is a good page. But not only for that reason, it is well written and met with equally awesome pictures. Photon never lets me down with his pages, and although this page does not have a completed history, should it ever be finished I am confident that it would be even awesomer.''

Final Rate: 7/10

Do you agree with Artemis´s Review?

The Batman
Artemis: ''This fan made film is REALLY good, I can't express how much I enjoyed reading it. And I must say the cast is really phenomenal, a lot of the choices Red Average made, I never would have thought of. Especially Milo Ventimiglia as Batman. I just recently started watching Heroes, and I've gotta say Red, great casting and great job.''

Final Rate: 8.5/10

Do you agree with Artemis´s Review?

Jean Grey (Earth-120986)
Artemis: ''Although the Mighty M is no longer with us, the greatness of his work lives on in the pages he created, such as Jean Grey. The great thing about M was that he was capable of thinking of the greatest twists possible while still making them seem completely normal and enjoyable to the character. He really cared about his characters, and that shows in Jean Grey. Her history is phenomenal and I love that her band name was Phoenix.''

Final Rate: 9,5/10

Do you agree with Artemis´s Review?

'''LET ,E JUST SAY THERE WILL BE A GALLERY, A TOP 4, AN INTERVIEW AND EVEN AN EXHIBITIO OF PHOTOS ON THIS EPISODE BUT I HAD TO PUBLISH IT NOW OR NOT TODAY I´M AFRAID. SO I´LL ADD THOSE THINGS LATER.'''